ReDoS Regular Expression Denial of Service

Posted March 4, 2013 by Taylor Fausak

Regular expression problems

On Thursday, I ran into a puzzling issue at work. It first occurred three weeks ago and remained uninvestigated because it appeared to be a duplicate of another issue. When I deployed the fix for the other issue, I expected it to fix this one too. Turns out, it didn’t.

So I took a closer look at it. A particular page sometimes timed out —   returned a 502 after 30 seconds. I suspected some sub-optimal SQL queries were to blame, so I reproduced it locally. That’s when things got weird.

The Rails logger stayed silent, meaning nothing was querying the database. I popped open OS X’s activity monitor and saw 100% CPU utilization but no RAM or disk usage. That was strange. It’s not often that our application hits a CPU bottleneck.

I dropped a debugger into the view, reloaded the page, and … nothing happened. It pegged my processor before it reached the break point. That meant a before filter was to blame, so I threw a debugger into those and chased down the offending line of code. It appeared completely benign:

  req.save if req.new_record? || req.changed?

Nothing particularly concerning about that. The validators that get called before saving the record are another matter entirely, though. In particular, that req object has a URL field. It’s checked against the following regular expression:

  %r{ https?:// # protocol (?:.+.)+ # subdomains [a-z]+/? # top level domain (?:[^./]+/?)* # path (?:[^.]+.[0-9a-z]+)? # file (?:[#?].*)? # query string or fragment }ix

(Before you pull out that Zawinski quote, I know this isn’t ideal. URI::regexp is better. That’s not the point.)

If you have an eagle eye for regexes, you might spot the problem right away. I didn’t, so I played with both the regex and URL until I whittled it down to this evil part:

  /^([^.\/]+\/?)*$/.match('0123456789012345678901234//')
That’s the path component of the pattern trying to match against a pathological string. I figured the problem was with nested repetition —   a + inside a group with a * isn’t a good sign. In fact, it’s listed as an example of an evil regex on Wikipedia’s ReDoS page.

I was curious about exactly what it was doing, so I fired up Perl to debug the regex, since Ruby doesn’t have a regex debugger. This script confirmed my suspicions:

  use re 'debugcolor'; '0123456789012345678901234//' =~ /^([^.\/]+\/?)*$/;

The solution was to rewrite the evil part of the pattern. The original regex tried too hard to break the URL into components, especially considering they weren’t being saved into match groups. The rewrite is a little more lax in that regard.

  %r{ https?:// # protocol (?:[-0-9a-z]+.)+ # subdomains [a-z]+ # top level domain (?: /[^#?]* # path (?:\?[^#]*)? # query string (?:#.*)? # fragment )? }ix

[Originally posted to my blog.]


Taylor Fausak was born in California, but he got to Texas as soon as he could. He studied Computer Science at the University of Texas at Austin before entering the wild world of software development. After a brief stint at Cisco, he started his career at Famigo working on all aspects of web development. Then he swapped his Django experience for a chunky slice of Rails bacon and joined OrgSync in the fall of 2012. When he's not slinging code around, he likes riding bikes, playing Magic, and throwing frisbees.


comments powered by Disqus